Saturday, March 24, 2007

Finally, a Lady with Balls!

As we are 'recovering' from the recent Philip Green vs. Maldivian culture clash, the nation is gripped with yet another controversy, once again religious in nature. This time the issue in focus is an article published in Minivan Daily written by MDP deputy secretary general Aishath Aaniya titled "Are women a social plague?". Some of the issues she wrote about deals with blind faith, excessive modesty obligations, gender inequalities, unwillingness to apply logic and even misinterpretation of holy scriptures and prophetic narrations. While I greatly admire Aaniya for her braveness in the face of our country's recently found religious conservatism, I was foolishly hoping that most people would at least give some thought to what she had said in the article.

After reading the comments posted under the article, I realized that I was wrong. Only a hand full of liberal minded personages praised her for her words of wisdom and act of bravery (for publishing something so bold), contrasted by the rest of the posts which were basically rants from amateur mullahs condemning her to the pits of Hell, calling her a blasphemer and finally passing judgment over her submission to God (To quote one of the comments "I doubt if at this point, you can be called a proper Muslim"). Its amusing the way these people think they are at liberty to criticize a sacred relationship between God and man by dubbing someone a heretic over an idea he merely expressed with good intentions.

However there was one particular post from an apparent doomsayer, which I found very provocative. It relates to Muhammad's narration of encountering tortured feminine souls on his visit to Hell, which took place on the night of the ascension. He described one particular woman hung from her hair with a boiling brain (due to the hellish heat) because she had refused to wear a veil during her life-time, along with various other grisly inexplicable methods of torture (which, ironically, you can only find in religion) for transgressions with varying degrees of gravity. If a mortal does anything like this, he would be called a "vengeful psychotic sadist with an insatiable taste for the macabre" (subsequent to being burned at the stake, once again, ironically) but since this narration supposedly comes from the prophet, we are led to believe it without contemplating its validity or logic or anything for that matter. Anyone who refuses to accept this or with the intellectual capacity to refute it is hastily called a blasphemer or worse. (For this reason I shall keep quiet on the commonly accepted nature of the divine). Blind faith prevails everywhere. My honest impression is that even some negative comments on that article seem to support Aaniya's cause for writing it.

Ultimately its not going to matter what we (meaning self-proclaimed liberals) think of this woman or her bold piece of writing in which she presents her arguments well, with seemingly flawless logic, fair reasoning and reverence of Islamic principles even though she was negating some of them. Most people who called her a blasphemer ignored these qualities of her writing and focused on superimposing their misguided religious dogmas acquired over years of ignorance. She is undoubtedly going to face repercussions, and if she is too proud to recant her arguments and publish an apology, she will almost surely get sacked regardless of what MDP thinks. The party would feel compelled to do so in an attempt to sanitize the organization and to maintain public trust. (One more reason to hate politics? I think so). Even if she does apologize in the course of the next few days I really can't help myself but to admire her for this single act of courage. After all, she has balls (in the metaphorical sense) that most of us can only dream of having.

Labels: , , ,

13 Comments:

Blogger Simon said...

Thanks for point out the ariticle in question.

Reading it was, and many would probably cringe at the thought, a breath of fresh air.

People don't like it when opinions are expressed about religion but someone has to do it.

12:06 PM, March 25, 2007  
Blogger f1x4n said...

People won't just "cringe" at the thought of you doing so, Simon, they wouldn't be content until they bury you up to the neck and stone you to death. This country is full of hypocrites. Everyone is begging for freedom of speech, but few people realize that its only limited to the political scenario, i.e. freedom to call each other "corrupt pigs". Expressions of sex, religious criticisms and serious social commentaries are still largely taboo. And this condition doesn't look like its going to improve any time soon, considering our society's shift towards a more conservative form of religion. I pray to God that we don't see a localized version of Saudi Arabia or Iran here.

12:50 PM, March 25, 2007  
Blogger Bakhabaru said...

It's amazing what anyone will believe if you just manage to put the fear of the unknown into their hearts first. I wasn't at all surprised to see some of the Mullahs calling her the "Maldivian Salman Rushdie" and issuing a fatwa on her.

Funny thing is that I doubt any of them have even read Rushdie's The Satanic Verses, which I found to be quite silly at times and not all that interesting... give me Midnight's Children anytime.

They are ready to believe the book is blasphemous when someone else tells them that it is so. Just like they believe that a woman should look like a black tent just because an amateur religious fanatic had proclaimed it so... where do they find these people so lacking in independent thoughts, anyway?

Voltaire was right when he said: "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities."

Our country is really going down the drain and most probably we won't even have drains if the mullahs have their way.

3:20 PM, March 25, 2007  
Blogger f1x4n said...

I don't know if you are familiar with the Colbert Report on Comedy Central (US) but if you watch the show, you'd frequently come across a term "truthiness" which is basically the first impression people get (gut feeling?) that supercedes the rest of their entire thinking (and acting) process. They do this while normally ignoring evidence, facts or even logic. Just like people in the American political scenario, Maldivians tend to persistantly embrace truthiness when it comes to religion. Err..and all other matters of life, come to think of it. Kudos to Voltaire, such words of wisdom.

Yeah, if the Mullahs have their way, we won't have drains, crotchless panties, birthday icing, HDTV sets, deodorants and washing soap. And oh, incidentially, we wouldn't have us either. Don't worry, fellow liberals. A choice of brainwashing, deportation or gallows is likely to be available.

5:10 PM, March 25, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

that aaniyaa is a chicken .. she doesnt even defend herself for her article ..

11:09 AM, March 26, 2007  
Blogger f1x4n said...

Dude, she already got the collective panties of all the mullahs (and even normal people) in a tight knot, if she starts defending that article, we'll see her whipped and probably even crucified (though I don't know how that'll wordk). Defending their religion and its policies (especially the ones Aaniya villified) is what people of this country should be doing, instead of obsessing on calling her the localized version of Rushdie.

11:14 AM, March 26, 2007  
Blogger psyph said...

In these times I would say, "ignorance is bliss"...seriusly. Fizz old boy, me being me, i wouldnt bother to even read their freakin comments on expressing a persons view on something.
For some people its just the easiest thing to say "damn u all to hell"

11:26 AM, March 26, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i mean to the guy who says shes gonna go to hyell i wonder who gave him the authority to say that...does he decides for god?...these people are outrageously funny ..i think they dont really mean what they say when they say it...damn extremism and bad interpretation of rteligion...alll i got for them is " shove a big stick up wherer the sun dont shine" pardon my french!

8:08 AM, March 27, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

f1x4n, u said: "I pray to God that we don't see a localized version of Saudi Arabia or Iran here."

Doesn't that sentence make you a hypocrite if you say what Aaniya said was absolutely correct?

It was God in the first place who said women had to wear veils.

10:27 AM, March 27, 2007  
Blogger f1x4n said...

Hi somebody, I don't claim to be an authorative figure on Islam neither do I deny being a hypocrite (we are all hypocrites, in varying degrees, aren't we?). As for the statement you quoted from me, I prayed never to see the day when religious practices would be forced upon us, like they do in the nations I mentioned. If I want to pray five times a day, which I very much do, then it should be upto my willingness to do so, not because of the fear of government endorsed religious police (In Saudi Arabia, they are called the 'Muttaween' or Committee for the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice. Check out their official website)

I don't think God commanded His followers to wear a headscarf or a veil, I think He specified what nudity is, and subsequently commanded us to practice modesty. So it really does not matter if women wear the veil, the full Hijab or even a raincoat as long as they dress themselves demurely, which once again, should be a matter of choice, not a social obligation.

I don't remember saying what Aaniya wrote about was entirely correct, not that I remember of anyway. She was wrong to claim that there is a lot of dispute between scholars about the 'veil' (actually what it implies). There isn't. They are just not able to come to an agreement on how to dress modestly, whether to wear that damn tent-like Hijab, permissibility of colored fabrics, acceptibility of the much less conservative headscard etc.

11:30 AM, March 27, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i think neither of us should comment on nething regarding religion if we dont know whts really right and wrong...if u feel like whts right for u than go ahead do it... but if u doubt its best u research or read on it.. its best not to believe wht people say abt religion and how we shud be,,.. its always advisable to learn more abt our religion and find out wht the right path is for ourselves,,, so we cant be on neone's side when it comes to religion... we will have to choose logically, morally think and understand, read and learn wht we are supposed to do and wht we are not supposed to do..

12:30 PM, March 27, 2007  
Blogger FehiNoo said...

As a fellow woman and some one who faces all the gender equality and bling faith on a daily basis in life, i congratulate aniya!

she was quite brave to talk about such a controversive issue and i am glad she chose to resign from her post rarther than spologize publicly for her beleifs.

we are all hypocrits. we all chose to bend religion yo our needs and wants. like aniya said the difference between animals and human beings are that we are given the power to think, and sadly very few people use that power.

while i was talking to a freind who does not wear the buruga and wears skimpy clothes, i was surprised at comments like aniya is not a muslim, kufuruvee, muruthadhu vee, coz aniya said that men and supermarkets should wear the veil. aniya did not exactly say that, she said gay feelings exist, and if women have to wear the veil coz men could do certain things because they may lose control, gay men and normal men should wear the veil to stop temptation. i completely agree with her on that!

secondly if i get raped coz someone saw the back of my neck, do i have to take responsibility for that? is that fair? how is that justice?

god, people wake up! ipen ur eyes to ur own blind faith. stop prosecuting other people for their beliefs. atleast aniya is better than us. she reasons out why she doesnt want to wear the buruga instead of the hypocrites among us who go arnd saying they will wear teh buruga when the time is right and say they blv in the veil when their actions contradict them

12:45 PM, March 27, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

shame on you guys for been called muslims.

10:34 PM, July 28, 2007  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home